- DEVIL’S ADVOCATES
- defeated The Premiere Payers to win the inaugural titles (18 April 2003)
- THE LUNATIC FRINGE
- defeated The Devil’s Advocates to win the titles (23 May 2003)
- defeated The Devil’s Advocates to retain the titles (20 June 2003)
- defeated The Premiere Players to retain the titles (22 August 2003)
- defeated The Grubby Holler Boys to retain the titles (11 October 2003)
- title declared vacant (Spring 2004)
3 – The Cleveland Mafia (Adam Cage & J-Rocc)
Vacant
- THE ENTOURAGE
- defeated Checkmate to win the vacant titles (14 April 2012)
- defeated Balls of Fury to retain the titles (07 July 2012)
- CHECKMATE
- defeated The Entourage to win the titles (07 October 2012)
- SHANE SABRE and CARTER MASON
- defeated Checkmate to win the titles (29 December 2013)
- CHECKMATE (2)
- defeated Sabre and Mason to win the titles (09 March 2014)
- defeated The Southern Vultures (14 September 2014)
- titles declared vacant due to promotional hiatus (Fall 2014)